Does Leonard truly know himself?

In Christopher Nolan’s film Memento, the main protagonist Leonard Shelby claims to know who he is despite suffering from anterograde amnesia. However, although he remembers his life prior to his accident, Leonard does not actually know the person he is now or has become. Leonard mainly relies on his past memory, his photographic evidence, his files and his general instincts to make conscious decisions. But because he has short term memory, he can be still be easily manipulated or place his trust in the wrong people. This causes him to (temporarily) change who he is or what he thinks he would/wouldn’t do. For example, when he comes to stay with Natalie at her house, he seems like a person who would never lose his cool or put his hands on a woman. However, when Natalie continues to berate him with insults and yells at Leonard, he loses his temper and hits Natalie in the face. And even though Natalie was trying to provoke him the entire time, Leonard has become a domestic abuser at this point. But once Natalie leaves the house and returns, Leonard has completely forgotten everything that’s happened and returned to a caring & understanding individual. If you were to ask Leonard if he would ever hit a woman, he would most likely say no. But we can see that Leonard does know himself as well as he thought because he hit Natalie. Perhaps if Leonard had time to write down what happened with Natalie and realized he was being used by her, he would have developed further as a character. But he would not even have been in that situation if he knew that the clothes he was wearing weren’t even his. This is why I believe that Leonard does not truly know himself as well as he claims to.

Leave a Reply